Later today, the President of the European Commission will deliver her 6th State of the Union speech to tell Europe what the EU plans to do next. Don’t expect millions of Europeans to tune in. Brussels pundits and media will spend the next 24 hours analysing every sentence, before a handful of headlines eventually filter out across Europe and its peripheries.
For weeks, business associations, NGOs, think tanks and advocacy groups have lobbied to get their issue, phrase or commitment into the speech. Being mentioned in SOTEU has obvious value for Brussels’ public-affairs industry: a public promise gives them something against which to hold the Commission to account. But it rarely determines whether a policy actually happens.
This year makes the point. The Commission can announce an EU Kids Act and propose making a European Security Council a reality. But neither can the Commission deliver alone: legislation requires agreement between the European Parliament and the Council, while a new security body requires political agreement among governments, and most likely treaty amendments going through national parliaments (not to mention asking permission from NATO lead and ally, the US). In other words, the Commission can set the agenda but cannot do so alone.
SOTEU is a relatively recent invention. Introduced in 2010, shortly after the Lisbon Treaty, it was designed to set out the Union’s political priorities, make them more transparent to citizens and hold the Commission accountable to Parliament. José Manuel Barroso, delivering the first address, called it a chance to “chart our work for the next 12 months.”
That purpose has since been diluted. SOTEU is now part political programme, part media event and largely a Brussels lobbying exercise for the few, not the many. Its evolution is reflected in its think-tankish style: hard figures mixed with slogans that fall flat, and little reach beyond an expert audience.
That matters more than it did in 2010. Europeans increasingly expect the EU to tackle problems national governments cannot solve alone, from security and energy to migration, climate, digital power, and competitiveness. Political allegiances may eventually shift from the capitals to the EU level, but the Union’s accountability mechanisms have not kept pace.
SOTEU’s democratic potential is to help close that gap. It should tell Europeans plainly what the EU can decide, what requires national governments, what can only be achieved together, and where Europe cannot act because Member States have not given it the authority, or more frequently - because they are preventing the Union from using the powers it already has.
That would make SOTEU less useful to lobbyists and more responsive to citizens.
The most useful State of the Union would focus less on what a few Brussels insiders want the Commission to say and more on what Europeans deserve to know: what the EU can do for them, and when national governments stand in its way.


